pdml@pdml.net

Pentax-Discuss Mail List

View all threads

Informal experiment, f/1.8 on APS v f/2.8 on K1

LC
Larry Colen
Mon, Dec 29, 2025 6:04 AM

This month I bought myself a couple of used lenses to console my bereft soul, either that, or I found them for prices that I couldn't resist.  I got the DFA 24-70/2.8 and the sigma 18-35/1.8.  The justification for spending the $400 on the sigma was that I don't have much that fast and wide of an AoV for APS.

Some years back I thought about how that lens on APS would compare with a 28-50 (or so) on FF.  You get about a stop faster lens, with about a stop smaller pixels. Also at equivalent fields of view, the depth of field should be similar. You lose some in the aperture, and you gain some in the focal length.

I did that test last night at the milonga.  Extremely informal.

Pretty much the same shot, at full wide focal length and wide open aperture both shot at 1/80 second. I did do TaV bracketing, but since both bodies are pretty much ISO invariant, difference in ISO is pretty much just the difference between where highlights blow out.

24-70 on the K-1
https://www.flickr.com/photos/ellarsee/55011389378/in/album-72177720331159947

18-35 on the K-3 iii
https://www.flickr.com/photos/ellarsee/55011211271/in/album-72177720331159947

Yeah, if I were to pixel peep, I might be able to notice differences, but in the real world, my conclusion is "close enough".

If you want to follow up yourself, the album is at:
https://www.flickr.com/photos/ellarsee/albums/72177720331159947/

The K1 shots are the LRC2xxxx and the K3 are LRC0xxxx.

For most of the evening, I shot with the 24-70 on the K-1 and the 85/1.4 on the K-3.

I think my favorite shots are
Olga:
https://www.flickr.com/photos/ellarsee/55011416549/in/album-72177720331159947

I've got another one of her that I absolutely love, except that I blew the focus. I posted it anyways.

Roseanna:
https://www.flickr.com/photos/ellarsee/55011209626/in/album-72177720331159947

And some dancers up in the balcony area where there was more room to dance:
https://www.flickr.com/photos/ellarsee/55011213051/in/album-72177720331159947

__
Larry Colen from Lothlorien
lrc@red4est.com

This month I bought myself a couple of used lenses to console my bereft soul, either that, or I found them for prices that I couldn't resist. I got the DFA 24-70/2.8 and the sigma 18-35/1.8. The justification for spending the $400 on the sigma was that I don't have much that fast and wide of an AoV for APS. Some years back I thought about how that lens on APS would compare with a 28-50 (or so) on FF. You get about a stop faster lens, with about a stop smaller pixels. Also at equivalent fields of view, the depth of field should be similar. You lose some in the aperture, and you gain some in the focal length. I did that test last night at the milonga. Extremely informal. Pretty much the same shot, at full wide focal length and wide open aperture both shot at 1/80 second. I did do TaV bracketing, but since both bodies are pretty much ISO invariant, difference in ISO is pretty much just the difference between where highlights blow out. 24-70 on the K-1 https://www.flickr.com/photos/ellarsee/55011389378/in/album-72177720331159947 18-35 on the K-3 iii https://www.flickr.com/photos/ellarsee/55011211271/in/album-72177720331159947 Yeah, if I were to pixel peep, I might be able to notice differences, but in the real world, my conclusion is "close enough". If you want to follow up yourself, the album is at: https://www.flickr.com/photos/ellarsee/albums/72177720331159947/ The K1 shots are the LRC2xxxx and the K3 are LRC0xxxx. For most of the evening, I shot with the 24-70 on the K-1 and the 85/1.4 on the K-3. I think my favorite shots are Olga: https://www.flickr.com/photos/ellarsee/55011416549/in/album-72177720331159947 I've got another one of her that I absolutely love, except that I blew the focus. I posted it anyways. Roseanna: https://www.flickr.com/photos/ellarsee/55011209626/in/album-72177720331159947 And some dancers up in the balcony area where there was more room to dance: https://www.flickr.com/photos/ellarsee/55011213051/in/album-72177720331159947 __ Larry Colen from Lothlorien lrc@red4est.com