Strange 360FGZ behaviour with K10D
pentaxlist at gmail.com
Wed Jan 10 06:38:38 EST 2007
Well in A mode it should read the parameters from the body *correctly*.
If then I want to override that's my problem but it should set the
parameters correctly at first.
Also, I don't see why I couldn't use A flash mode when I use anything
else than M camera mode. This si very stupid and BTW if I judge PTTL
not to my taste I should be able to use A mode. So yes I'm quite
annoyed but this.
I will check with my Z1 how it reacts.
Could someone check with a 360 and MZ-S and a K10D and 540 FGZ ??
2007/1/10, Bruce Dayton <bkdayton at daytonphoto.com>:
> My understanding and usage of A mode is that there is a sensor on the
> flash that is used instead of the one in the body. The flash can be
> set to any parameters that you want, independent of the body. This
> allows you to control the flash as you want. It lets you do fill
> flash by telling the flash that it is brighter than it really is.
> So although it initially reads the ISO the body has set, it can be
> It sounds to me that your flash is working as it is supposed to. I
> have had 2 AF360FGZ's for several years and they have been working all
> along. They work exactly as you describe on the K10D. Basically you
> either live with P-TTL mode and flash settable compensation, or you
> switch to A or M and control the flash as you like.
> Tuesday, January 9, 2007, 2:32:30 PM, you wrote:
> T> Very weird.
> T> I can confirm that even with fresh batteries (alkaline but well they
> T> provide 1.5V each and were perfectly new one) that unless in M mode
> T> (camera) I can only choose PTTL or SB.
> T> Also, it will not show correct parameters when in A mode (flash) and M
> T> mode (camera). My FA50/1.4 exhibits the same problem ad my FA 100/3.5
> T> MAcro.
> T> Defenitely not bettery related.
> T> So either the camera(firmware?) or flash is faulty !
> T> 2007/1/9, Bruce Dayton <bkdayton at daytonphoto.com>:
> >> Hmmm....I just put one of my AF360FGZ flashes on my K10D and was able
> >> to cycle between P-TTL, A, M and SB. The lens in place was the DA
> >> 16-45/4.
> >> --
> >> Best regards,
> >> Bruce
> >> Tuesday, January 9, 2007, 11:37:02 AM, you wrote:
> >> T> Here are a couple observations since I took time to play a bit with
> >> T> external flash on my K10D. I have no other flash to test to compare
> >> T> results.
> >> T> * Exposure seems to be mostly OK (PTTL mode). At least way better than
> >> T> RTF which tends to overexpose (based on my short experience since I
> >> T> have had my K10D for only a couple days).
> >> T> * Mode selection on the flash itself is screwed up. Basicaly, except
> >> T> in M mode, I can only choose P-TTL or SB (AF assist only). Not having
> >> T> TTL is of course normal but I cannot access A mode nor M mode which is
> >> T> weird to say the least. Pushing mode button will cycle between PTTL
> >> T> and SB , period.
> >> T> * M mode allows to select A mode and M mode but... It seems appart
> >> T> from the ISO, the exposure parameters are not shown correctly on the
> >> T> flash screen. I was using FA 100/3.5 macro and the screen showed f/2.8
> >> T> !! However the camera of course showed correct info. Also, the flashed
> >> T> showed 58mm as max zoom. It'd be correct with an DA lens but with an
> >> T> FA lens it is very.. disturbing !!
> >> T> * If I let the flash powered-on and do power-off the camera and then
> >> T> back on, I can choose whatever mode until I take a picture. After this
> >> T> picture the camera forces again the flash to only accept PTTL and SB.
> >> T> * In the couple shots I tried in A mode (using the power on/off trick)
> >> T> exposure didn't seem far off but it is way to early to traw a
> >> T> conclusion as far as I'm concerned.
> >> T> Now, a firmware update will hopefully take care of this. They'd
> >> T> better. Or then upgrade the flash but that'd be harder ...
> >> T> It doesn't change my love for this camera. I don't like using flash,
> >> T> probably because I'm unable to do it well enough but that won't help
> >> T> me for sure ;)
> >> T> Is somebody able to confirm this behaviour and maybe try with a 540FGZ
> >> T> ? I guess it works the same way as IMO the camera is the culprit here.
> >> T> --
> >> T> Thibault Massart aka Thibouille
> >> T> ----------------------
> >> T> *ist-D,Z1,SuperA,KX,MX, P30t and KR-10x ;) ...
> >> --
> >> PDML Pentax-Discuss Mail List
> >> PDML at pdml.net
> >> http://pdml.net/mailman/listinfo/pdml_pdml.net
> T> --
> T> Thibault Massart aka Thibouille
> T> ----------------------
> T> *ist-D,Z1,SuperA,KX,MX, P30t and KR-10x ;) ...
> PDML Pentax-Discuss Mail List
> PDML at pdml.net
Thibault Massart aka Thibouille
*ist-D,Z1,SuperA,KX,MX, P30t and KR-10x ;) ...
More information about the PDML